April 17, 2006
Planning Board Minutes
Oswego Town Hall
Chair: Judy Sabin-Watson
Town Board Members: Francis Dellamano, Kenneth Kern,
Lee Phillips, Barry Pritchard, Jeffrey Boyer, James Finn
Attorney To The Board: Stephen Greene, Jr.
Call to Order:

At approximately 7:00 PM, Judy Watson, Chairman of the Planning Board called the meeting to order.

Attendance:

Those in attendance were:
Chair
Member
Member
Member
Member
Attorney
Secretary
Judy Sabin-Watson
Lee Phillips
Barry Pritchard
James Finn
Jeffrey Boyer
Stephen Greene, Jr.
Marjorie Best
Those absent were:
Member
Member
Francis Dellamano
Kenneth Kern
Old Business:

Approval of March 20, 2006 Minutes:

Lee Phillips made a motion that the Minutes of March 20, 2006 be approved. Barry Pritchard seconded the motion. All ayes. Motion carried.

New Business:

Public Comment:

Bob Dexter, a new Zoning Board Member appeared at the meeting, as he was interested in the Open Board Discussion regarding the Local Energy Tower Rules and Regulations of Cellular Telephone Towers and Antennas.

Open Board Discussion:

Judy Watson said she hoped everyone had a chance to read the documents Steve had given the members last month on Local Energy Tower Rules; Municipal Regulations of Cellular Telephone Towers and Antennas; Wind Turbines and Noise; and Letters to the Planning Board. Judy stated she found the packet of material very interesting.

Judy had a question on a word she did not understand in the Local Energy Tower Rules on the second page "ambient nighttime level". Jeff Boyer explained that it would be the normal noise level at night. There was discussion as to how many towers should be on a parcel of land. Judy quoted on Page 1 of the Local Energy Tower Rules - Limitation of Number - "There shall be a limit of one (1) energy deriving tower per parcel".

Barry Pritchard mentioned Subdivisions. After some discussion, it was decided to strike - "There shall be a limit of one (1) energy-deriving tower per parcel". If someone had a lot of property, they could put more than one up. Steve quoted the same section, Page 2 - "Guy wires and anchors for towers shall not be located closer than one-half (Ω) of the height of the tower to any property line."

Judy was trying to think of something else we had discussed regarding towers, and Lee Phillips said we had discussed it when we went over Cell Towers. Bob Dexter asked about the procedure as to installing a tower. Jim Finn said no one can put one up without applying for a Variance, and must provide a Site Plan. Lee said it would go to the Zoning Board for approval. Steve stated this is all explained on Page 1 - Permit Application, No. 2. Steve referred to Page 1, under Exemptions, No. 2 should be stricken. Lee Phillips mentioned that two towers would give twice the energy. Barry Pritchard said the tower would not go on somebody else's property. He also mentioned if they put a tower up, it should be taken down and cleaned every so many years. Judy said maybe every 5 years, and Barry agreed.

Steve Greene said there should be a Performance Bond. After some discussion, Steve said he would draft it up. Lee Phillips said a permit should be applied for to build a wind mill, not an antenna. Judy said we have to talk about energy power, as opposed to some other kinds of power. Jeff again brought up the subject of energy deriving towers shall not produce a level of noise at any lot line greater than the ambient nighttime level. Noise reduction technology shall be installed as a condition of approval if it is determined by the Planning Board that the noise levels are exceeded after installation occurs.

Judy said one of the sections we talked about was elevated structures, rather than telecommunication towers and antennas. Steve said we should merge wind mills with it. Judy said this section should go back to what we originally had. Jim Finn said towers are to be considered a utility. Lee Phillips said we had to have a whole list of things they had to comply with, such as a Bond. Barry ask if they didn't apply on Tug Hill Road a couple of years ago. Lee Phillips said they stopped that one, and put it out by the college. He also said they wanted to put one on Cemetery Road and Route 104. Barry said there are companies who want to put these things up.

Judy said it looks like we have gone over all the various sections. Lee Phillips asked about Adult Uses, and Judy said we had gone over that one. She said she has all the sections scratched up except Special Use. She stated the secretary volunteered to type all the corrections to the sections. Judy told the secretary to specify sections, and not just by X's Jim Finn asked if we would have them before the next meeting, and the secretary said she always sends the packets to the members a week before the meeting.

At approximately 7:45 PM, Lee Phillips made a motion to adjourn the meeting. Jeff Boyer seconded the Motion. All ayes. Motion carried.


Respectfully submitted,

Marjorie Best,
Secretary to Planning Board
Back to 2006 Planning Board Agendas & Minutes
Back to Planning Board Web Page
Top of Page